Toxic Delugeremoval$7.62Efficient black creature wipe that scales to remove multiple threats, often filling the same role as a premium removal spell. It is usually stronger overall, though it hits your own board too.
Damnationremoval$18.83Straightforward unconditional board wipe in black, serving as a cleaner mass-removal option for creatures. It is stronger at removing multiple creatures, though it is not targeted exile.
Deadly Tempestremoval$0.94Mass removal that clears creatures while punishing their controller, which overlaps with the life-loss drawback style of Ashes to Ashes. It is slower, but can be devastating in creature-heavy boards.
LanguishremovalBudget$0.34Black sweeper that can clean up multiple non-flying creatures at once, similar in being a mid-cost black answer to board presence. It is less precise than Ashes to Ashes but often more efficient against wide boards.
Extinction Eventremoval$0.91Flexible black sweeper that exiles many creatures based on mana value, giving black access to exile-based mass removal. It is not targeted, but it can remove two or more key creatures efficiently.
Hero's DownfallremovalBudget$0.14Classic black removal spell that kills a creature or planeswalker, making it a flexible main-deck answer. It is not exile, but it fills the same single-target removal slot.
Feed the Swarmremoval$0.79Black removal that can answer creatures or enchantments, giving black a flexible answer to permanents it normally struggles with. It is sorcery-speed and not exile, but it is a useful similar-role removal spell.
Oblivion RingremovalBudget$0.21Universal exile removal for a nonland permanent, often used as a comparable answer to troublesome creatures. It is white rather than black, but it serves a very similar functional role.